Sometimes I have a feeling about a book and where it might fall on my own reviewer scale, even before I pick it up and start reading.
This was one of those books. I thought it would be a book that was good but not great. Sometimes fictionalized accounts of historical figures lives can go very right or very wrong. I am not a big Jack London fan or a Harry Houdini fan….so I was ready to put this book firmly in the three star category before I even started the first page.
San Francisco, 1915. As America teeters on the brink of world war, Charmian and her husband, famed novelist Jack London, wrestle with genius and desire, politics and marital competitiveness.
Charmian longs to be viewed as an equal partner who put her own career on hold to support her husband, but Jack doesn’t see it that way…until Charmian is pulled from the audience during a magic show by escape artist Harry Houdini, a man enmeshed in his own complicated marriage. Suddenly, charmed by the attention Houdini pays her and entranced by his sexual magnetism, Charmian’s eyes open to a world of possibilities that could be her escape.
As Charmian grapples with her urge to explore the forbidden, Jack’s increasingly reckless behavior threatens her dedication. Now torn between two of history’s most mysterious and charismatic figures, she must find the courage to forge her own path, even as she fears the loss of everything she holds dear (summary from Goodreads).
Sometimes we are just primed to love or hate a book based on a cover, a review or even publicity flooding. There has been a lot of buzz about this book and the cover is lovely to look at but for me I just wasn’t sure I was going to love it, which is completely unfair I know but sometimes it just happens.
That said, I felt like I owed it to the author to give it a fair shot and try to not place it firmly in the category of ‘ok’. After a few chapters, I realized I was reading something more than just ok. I don’t know much–ok anything–about Jack London and his personal life. i haven’t read his novels and frankly have zero desire to read them, so this novel was a little hard to get into especially if you don’t have any background on the famous couple.
Once I got my bearings of their lives and some background, I was able to really get lost in the romance story. Jack London was a complicated character and I liked seeing how Rosenberg depicted him in the novel. Charmian is so wrapped up in Jack that I often felt that she didn’t even know who she was without him. Talk about codependent. But as we got to know her in the story, it was clear that she had this unrealistic ideal of what romance was or was supposed to be especially when it came to Jack.
Complicated marriage is such a basic way to describe their marriage but yet if I try to describe it any other way, it takes on a life of it’s own so lets just leave it as ‘it’s complicated’. I loved how honest that part was.
The ‘friendship’ Charmian had with Harry and his wife was dramatic. When I say dramatic what I really mean is superficial. I couldn’t help but feel that Charmian was clearly NOT a friend to Harry’s wife and I don’t think she was meant to be a real friend to her even from the beginning. I enjoyed seeing how different the relationship was between all the characters. This book was so clearly about moral ambiguity and how easy those lines can be blurred and how easy it is to idealized people and their situations.
I thought about this book a long time after I read it and often I found myself wondering what would I do if I were in Charmian’s place. For me the fact that I kept coming back to this story was a sign of a great read. While I sometimes didn’t always like Charmian and her choices, I liked the complexity of the novel and it was so much more than a three star book. Lovely writing and engaging story that will leave readers questioning and wondering about the real lives of some of America’s most well known figures.
Be sure to check out other stops on the virtual book tour where you can read author interviews, enter giveaways, and read other reviews.
Book: The Secret Life of Mrs London by Rebecca Rosenberg
Kindle Edition, 348 pagesPublished January 30th 2018 by Lake Union Publishing
- Review copy provided by: Author/Publisher in exchange for an honest review
This book counts toward: NA
- Hosted by: NA
- Books for Challenge Completed: NA
Recommendation: 4 out of 5
Genre: Historical fiction
Memorable lines/quotes: NA
Blog Tour Schedule
Tuesday, January 30
Review at A Bookaholic Swede
Wednesday, January 31
Interview & Giveaway at Passages to the Past
Thursday, February 1
Guest Post at Let Them Read Books
Feature at What Is That Book About
Friday, February 2
Review at View from the Birdhouse
Feature at Historical Fiction with Spirit
Monday, February 5
Review at Creating Herstory
Tuesday, February 6
Review at Planting Cabbages
Wednesday, February 7
Review at A Bookish Affair
Thursday, February 8
Interview at Planting Cabbages
Friday, February 9
Review at Bookish
Sunday, February 11
Review at Carole’s Ramblings
Monday, February 12
Review at Cup of Sensibility
Tuesday, February 13
Review & Giveaway at The Maiden’s Court
Wednesday, February 14
Review at Donna’s Book Blog
Thursday, February 15
Review at Jorie Loves a Story
Friday, February 16
Guest Post at Short Book and Scribes
Monday, February 19
Review at Reading the Past
Tuesday, February 20
Review at The Lit Bitch
Friday, February 23
Review at Pursuing Stacie
Review at History From a Woman’s Perspective
Monday, February 26
Review at Back Porchervations
Tuesday, February 27
Guest Post at My Reading Corner
Wednesday, February 28
Review & Giveaway at Suzy Approved Book Reviews
Thursday, March 1
Review at What Cathy Read Next
Friday, March 2
Review at Svetlana’s Reads and Views
Monday, March 5
Review at Caryn, the Book Whisperer
Tuesday, March 6
Review at Bookish Beck
4 thoughts on “Review: The Secret Life of Mrs. London by Rebecca Rosenberg”
Thanks for such a wonderful and honest review. It’s on my TRL
Looking forward to reading it..
Lucky4750 at aol dot com
Yeah, I am so happy that you enjoyed it more than you expected. I love it when that happens! Great review!
I hope you will stop by the Online Book Release Party tonight with Rebecca Rosenberg: https://www.facebook.com/events/769428619911995
HF Virtual Book Tours
Hallo, Hallo 🙂
*At long last, I’m able to return,…*
I had a suspicion we’ve been on several tours together – I wasn’t sure if we were on this one until I spied your tweets about it recently! I thought it was quite lovely of the author to ‘quote’ from our reviews and give us quote cards for Twitter! 🙂 Very lovely of her and it was nice knowing she was pulling out different thoughts and perspectives from what we were all sharing whilst we ruminated about the story itself.
As you might have already seen – I had some issues with the context of the story but also, in the end, what bothered me a bit is how the actual story deviated a bit too widely away from the reality of the characters’ lives IRL. I do admit, I held on to see how it would conclude – but I found it to be a more conflicted reading experience wherein what I said on Twitter about Zelda having a better life truly is my final takeaway. She found peace at the end of her life (despite the tragedy) and understood who she was a creative woman, a painter and a writer. She owned her uniqueness and a lot of what she struggled with melted away through self-acceptance and understanding of what caused all her health ailments. I didn’t step away from reading about Mrs London feeling the same kind of ‘resolution’ to her life’s woes or her saucy inclinations towards causal relationships and hookups. To me she felt more self-centred and self-motivating towards doing what appeased her own desires rather than being a true second half to any of the men in her life; plus I was bothered by how she treated Bess Houdini.
I guess you could say having felt attached to Zelda, I struggled to understand Mrs London and I think that struggle to find traction is seen in what I blogged.
I was thrilled when I read your thoughts about Bess! 🙂 I was surprised others hadn’t been noticing this tendency to be superficially positive in the lives of women Mrs London interacted with as I felt it was one of her cardinal faults.
I loved reading your thoughts!! You always put your heart into how you talk about your reading life and it’s lovely to visit with you! 🙂 Are you participating in the HistFic Reading Challenge on Passages to the Past? I’m finally getting ‘active’ after years of tracking my progress outside official participation! lol I’m finding by adding my links to the linkys more HistFic lovers have been finding me lately which is a nice unexpected JOY.